Written by

There is something peculiar about being a cyclist. You can own a perfectly functional bicycle, one that takes you wherever you want to go, provides countless hours of enjoyment and has absolutely nothing wrong with it, yet still find yourself convinced that something needs changing. Your the wheels could be lighter, the handlebars more comfortable, or the brakes a little more powerful. Perhaps you have spent an evening looking at beautifully machined components, and now the perfectly adequate ones on your bicycle seem strangely disappointing.

Nothing has actually changed. The bicycle still works exactly as it did yesterday, the trails haven’t become more demanding, and your riding ability remains much the same. Yet somehow, you’ve discovered a deficiency that didn’t previously exist. I suspect the bicycle industry depends rather heavily on our ability to experience this peculiar form of dissatisfaction.

Of course, bicycles have always been objects of desire as well as practical machines. There is nothing inherently wrong with appreciating beautiful engineering, enjoying mechanical experimentation or purchasing something simply because we like it. But there’s an important distinction between wanting a new component and believing that our existing one is inadequate. The bicycle industry operates within an economic system that benefits from continued consumption, and one way to maintain that consumption is to encourage the perception that whatever we currently own could be improved. New technologies promise greater efficiency, improved comfort, increased performance or enhanced reliability. Sometimes these developments represent genuine progress. At other times, the improvement is less obvious, and the perceived inadequacy of existing equipment becomes more important than any measurable difference. The bicycle hasn’t necessarily become obsolete. Our expectations have simply changed.

What makes this intriguing is that even cycling communities that appear to reject mainstream consumerism can reproduce exactly the same behaviour. Consider the current enthusiasm for rebuilding mountain bikes from the 1990s. On the surface, this movement represents something rather wonderful. People are rescuing old bicycles, rediscovering the pleasures of steel frames, rigid forks and uncomplicated mechanical systems, and rejecting the assumption that enjoying cycling requires the latest technology. A thirty-year-old mountain bike can still be an excellent means of transport, a capable machine for exploring woodland trails and a perfectly enjoyable way to spend an afternoon. It might even have the considerable advantage of being relatively inexpensive. Here, surely, is a small rebellion against an industry that constantly encourages us to purchase something new.

Except, of course, we then start upgrading them.

The original brakes are replaced with beautifully machined Paul Components. The handlebars come from an obscure manufacturer whose products cost considerably more than their appearance might suggest. We add a boutique stem, a desirable saddle, some colourful anodised components and a selection of carefully considered accessories. Suddenly, the cheap old mountain bike has become a rather expensive exercise in simplicity. We’ve rejected the latest carbon frame, electronic shifting and the endless pursuit of technological advancement, only to discover an entirely different collection of expensive things we apparently need. The bicycle might be thirty years old, but our relationship with consumerism is remarkably contemporary.

Pierre Bourdieu

The French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu offers a way of understanding this contradiction. In Distinction, Bourdieu explored how taste operates as a means of establishing and communicating social differences. Our preferences are not simply expressions of individual desire. They are also shaped by the social environments we inhabit, and our knowledge of what is considered desirable can become a form of cultural capital. Within cycling, owning the most expensive bicycle isn’t necessarily the most effective way of demonstrating status. In certain communities, knowing which obscure components belong on a thirty-year-old mountain bike can communicate far more than arriving on the latest high-end carbon machine. The bicycle becomes a demonstration not simply of wealth, but of knowledge, taste and cultural belonging.

This creates an interesting form of consumerism because it can disguise itself as a rejection of consumerism. We’re no longer displaying status by owning the newest technology. Instead, we’re displaying our understanding of what constitutes an authentic alternative. A carefully restored mountain bike with the right components communicates that we appreciate craftsmanship, mechanical simplicity and cycling history. These are perfectly reasonable things to value, but they can also become another set of expectations against which we judge ourselves and others. What began as a movement celebrating the possibilities of inexpensive old bicycles risks developing its own expensive standards of participation. The cyclist who simply maintains their original Shimano components might have a perfectly functional bicycle, but the cyclist with the beautifully machined boutique brakes possesses something more culturally desirable.

There is a broader philosophical contradiction here. Capitalism has a remarkable ability to absorb the very cultures that appear to resist it. The cultural theorist Mark Fisher explored how opposition to capitalism can be incorporated into commercial culture, allowing dissatisfaction with the system to become another opportunity for consumption. We can see something similar in cycling. If riders become disillusioned with expensive modern bicycles, the market can offer expensive interpretations of traditional bicycles instead. If we reject technological complexity, we can purchase beautifully engineered simplicity. If we reject mass production, we can consume craftsmanship and individuality. The products change, and the language surrounding them changes, but the underlying relationship between desire, identity and purchasing can remain remarkably consistent. Even our resistance can acquire a price tag.

None of this means that buying expensive components is inherently wrong. Small manufacturers often produce excellent products, support skilled employment and provide repairable components that can keep older bicycles functioning for decades. There is also genuine pleasure in building something beautiful, and I wouldn’t want to suggest that every purchase must be justified through measurable performance improvements. Sometimes we simply want something because it makes us happy. I rather like beautifully made bicycle components myself, which makes criticising them slightly inconvenient. The problem isn’t that we desire these objects. The problem emerges when desire becomes confused with necessity, when the enjoyment of something we already own becomes dependent upon acquiring something else.

Social media undoubtedly complicates this relationship. We encounter endless photographs of carefully assembled bicycles, each presenting an apparently individual interpretation of cycling culture. Certain components, colours and arrangements become familiar, then desirable, and eventually begin to establish an informal aesthetic standard. Nobody necessarily tells us that our bicycle is inadequate. We simply absorb the repeated suggestion that a more beautiful, more authentic or more culturally appropriate version exists. And because these expectations often emerge from fellow enthusiasts rather than conventional advertisements, they can feel entirely natural. The community helps create the desire, and the industry provides the objects through which we attempt to satisfy it.

The most revealing aspect of this is that the bicycle’s fundamental purpose can become almost secondary. We spend considerable time thinking about what a bicycle is, what it represents and how its components reflect our identities, while occasionally forgetting what it actually allows us to do. A bicycle enables movement, exploration, independence and a particular relationship with the world around us. Those experiences aren’t necessarily improved by the addition of more expensive components. Indeed, some of the most enjoyable rides happen on entirely unremarkable bicycles, where the machine gradually disappears from our conscious attention and the experience becomes about the terrain, the movement and the simple pleasure of being somewhere else.

And that is where the real possibility for resistance lies. Not in rejecting expensive bicycles, insisting that everyone ride old steel frames or establishing another hierarchy based on who spends the least money. That would merely replace one set of expectations with another. Instead, we should question the assumption that improvement must always involve purchasing something. Sometimes improvement means developing our skills, becoming more familiar with the bicycle we already own, or discovering new possibilities within its existing limitations. Sometimes it means repairing something rather than replacing it. And sometimes it simply means recognising that the machine is already good enough.

The bicycle industry profits when we concentrate on what our bicycles lack. Cycling culture can reinforce that feeling, even when it believes itself to be resisting it. Yet the experience of riding offers a rather different perspective. When we’re negotiating a muddy trail, climbing through woodland or simply enjoying the freedom of travelling under our own power, the cultural significance of our components often becomes irrelevant. The bicycle doesn’t need to establish our status, demonstrate our taste or justify its existence through continual improvement. It simply needs to work.

Teh most radical thing we can do in a culture that continually manufactures dissatisfaction is to look at the bicycle we already own and decide that, for now, it is enough.

And then go for a ride.

One response

Leave a Reply